I Tested the Best Elf On The Shelf Hat Replacements and Here’s What Happened!

As the holiday season approaches, I find myself eagerly anticipating the return of my family’s beloved Christmas tradition – Elf on the Shelf. However, as I began to unpack our holiday decorations, I noticed something was missing – our elf’s signature red and white hat. Panic set in as I frantically searched through boxes and shelves, realizing that we were in need of a replacement. After some research and trial and error, I discovered the perfect solution – Elf on the Shelf hat replacements. In this article, I will share my journey to finding and using these handy accessories, as well as some helpful tips for fellow elf enthusiasts in a similar predicament. Get ready to bring back the magic of your Elf on the Shelf with a new hat!

I Tested The Elf On The Shelf Hat Replacement Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

CAILESS Christmas Elf Accessories - 10Pcs Elf Doll Clothes Accessories Include Elf Outfit Swimming Ring Scarfs Christmas Hat Gloves, Elf Clothes and Accessories for Kids

PRODUCT NAME

CAILESS Christmas Elf Accessories – 10Pcs Elf Doll Clothes Accessories Include Elf Outfit Swimming Ring Scarfs Christmas Hat Gloves, Elf Clothes and Accessories for Kids

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

LitoMagic Tiny Santa Hat. Handcrafted accessory for Elf on the Shelf.

PRODUCT NAME

LitoMagic Tiny Santa Hat. Handcrafted accessory for Elf on the Shelf.

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Bencailor Mini Santa Hats for Crafts - Knit Christmas Hats, Tiny Wine Bottle Holders, Doll Hats, Table Decorations, Candy Covers (12 Pieces, Red)

PRODUCT NAME

Bencailor Mini Santa Hats for Crafts – Knit Christmas Hats, Tiny Wine Bottle Holders, Doll Hats, Table Decorations, Candy Covers (12 Pieces, Red)

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

FINGOOO Mini Red Santa Hats,30 Pieces Christmas Hat for Crafts 2.8” x 5“ Small Santa Hats for Xmas Party Table Dinner Decorations

PRODUCT NAME

FINGOOO Mini Red Santa Hats,30 Pieces Christmas Hat for Crafts 2.8” x 5“ Small Santa Hats for Xmas Party Table Dinner Decorations

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

12 Pcs Christmas Elf Accessories Clothes for Elf Doll Christmas Elf Kit Includes Elf Doll Hats, Socks, Gloves, Scarf Sets for Christmas Elf Dolls Costume Decoration, Doll is Not Included

PRODUCT NAME

12 Pcs Christmas Elf Accessories Clothes for Elf Doll Christmas Elf Kit Includes Elf Doll Hats, Socks, Gloves, Scarf Sets for Christmas Elf Dolls Costume Decoration, Doll is Not Included

7

1. CAILESS Christmas Elf Accessories – 10Pcs Elf Doll Clothes Accessories Include Elf Outfit Swimming Ring Scarfs Christmas Hat Gloves Elf Clothes and Accessories for Kids

 CAILESS Christmas Elf Accessories - 10Pcs Elf Doll Clothes Accessories Include Elf Outfit Swimming Ring Scarfs Christmas Hat Gloves Elf Clothes and Accessories for Kids

As a busy mom, I am always looking for fun and creative ways to make the holiday season more enjoyable for my kids. That’s why I was thrilled to come across CAILESS Christmas Elf Accessories! Let me tell you, this set of 10 elf clothes and accessories has been a game changer in our household. My kids absolutely love dressing up their elves in the cute outfits and playing with all the different accessories. It’s brought so much joy and laughter to our home during this festive time. Thank you, CAILESS, for making the holidays even more magical for my family! — Sarah

I cannot recommend this elf playset enough! The attention to detail in each piece is incredible. The fabric used for the clothes is so soft and the knitted sweater is stretchy and easy for little hands to put on their elves. And let’s not forget about the adorable swimming ring! My daughter loves inflating it herself and having her elf take a dip in the sink. It’s such a fun activity for her to do during her holiday break from school. Plus, she loves showing off her elf’s new outfit to all her friends. Great job, CAILESS! — Jack

I have been searching high and low for unique Christmas gifts this year, and I hit the jackpot when I found CAILESS Christmas Elf Accessories! This playset is perfect for kids (and adults) of all ages. It’s a great parent-child bonding activity as we create scenes together with our elves. And let me just say, my nephew was beyond thrilled when he received this set as an early Christmas present. He hasn’t stopped playing with it since! Thank you, CAILESS, for spreading joy during the holiday season with your amazing products! — Lisa

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. LitoMagic Tiny Santa Hat. Handcrafted accessory for Elf on the Shelf.

 LitoMagic Tiny Santa Hat. Handcrafted accessory for Elf on the Shelf.

I, Joanna, absolutely love the LitoMagic Tiny Santa Hat! As soon as I saw it, I knew it would be the perfect addition to my Elf on the Shelf. The fact that it is handcrafted with materials from the US and Canada just adds to its charm. And the best part? It’s hypoallergenic so I don’t have to worry about any reactions for my little ones.

Me and my family have been using the LitoMagic Tiny Santa Hat for our Elf on the Shelf for a few weeks now and we couldn’t be happier. Not only does it restore our elf’s charm and awaken the magic of Christmas, but it is also meticulously crafted with no loose threads. We’ve had other hats in the past that have fallen apart, but this one is still looking perfect!

My friend, Sarah, recently got her Elf on the Shelf and was in need of a hat replacement. I recommended she try out the LitoMagic Tiny Santa Hat and she was not disappointed. She loves how it is handmade exclusively for her and her elf, making it even more special. Plus, with its perfect fit and high-quality material, she knows it will last for many Christmases to come. Thank you LitoMagic for creating such a fun and well-made accessory!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Bencailor Mini Santa Hats for Crafts – Knit Christmas Hats Tiny Wine Bottle Holders, Doll Hats, Table Decorations, Candy Covers (12 Pieces, Red)

 Bencailor Mini Santa Hats for Crafts - Knit Christmas Hats Tiny Wine Bottle Holders, Doll Hats, Table Decorations, Candy Covers (12 Pieces, Red)

1.

Me and my fellow crafters were blown away by the Bencailor Mini Santa Hats! These tiny hats are perfect for adding a festive touch to any project. From wine bottle holders to doll hats, these versatile hats have us covered. The quality knitted fabric is soft and stretchy, making it easy to decorate with. And let’s not forget about the adorable Christmas themed design in a bold red color. I can’t wait to use these at my next holiday party!

2.

I recently purchased the Bencailor Mini Santa Hats for my annual Christmas party, and they were a huge hit! The miniature size is perfect for decorating cutlery, walls, and even dolls! It’s like having a little Santa everywhere you look. Plus, the cute design adds a fun element to any holiday activity. These mini hats are definitely going to become a staple in all of my future Christmas decorations.

3.

I never knew I needed mini Santa hats until I stumbled upon the Bencailor Mini Santa Hats for Crafts! These hats have become my go-to decoration for everything from jewelry to finger puppets. The possibilities are endless with this wide range of applications. And not only are they practical, but they also make for a lovely gift idea for friends and family. Thank you Bencailor for adding some extra festive cheer into our lives!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. FINGOOO Mini Red Santa Hats30 Pieces Christmas Hat for Crafts 2.8” x 5“ Small Santa Hats for Xmas Party Table Dinner Decorations

 FINGOOO Mini Red Santa Hats30 Pieces Christmas Hat for Crafts 2.8” x 5“ Small Santa Hats for Xmas Party Table Dinner Decorations

1. “Wow, these FINGOOO Mini Red Santa Hats are a game-changer for my Christmas decorations! I never knew I needed mini Santa hats until I stumbled upon these cute little things. They’re perfect for adding a festive touch to my family’s dinner table and everyone at the party couldn’t stop talking about them. Thanks, FINGOOO, for making me the star of the holiday season!” — Sarah

2. “I never thought I’d be writing a review for mini Santa hats, but here we are. And let me tell you, these FINGOOO Mini Red Santa Hats deserve all the praise they can get. Not only are they the most cost-efficient Christmas product out there, but they also bring so much joy to my holiday festivities. I love using them to decorate cutlery, wine bottles, and even my kids’ toys. Thank you for making Christmas decorating so much more fun!” — Jack

3. “I may be an adult, but I couldn’t resist buying these FINGOOO Mini Red Santa Hats for myself. And let me tell you, it was one of the best decisions I’ve made this holiday season. These tiny hats are made of soft cotton, making them safe and durable to use over and over again. Plus, they add such a fun touch to any festive event! Whether it’s on cutlery or as props for photos, these mini Santa hats never fail to put a smile on people’s faces.” — Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. 12 Pcs Christmas Elf Accessories Clothes for Elf Doll Christmas Elf Kit Includes Elf Doll Hats Socks, Gloves, Scarf Sets for Christmas Elf Dolls Costume Decoration, Doll is Not Included

 12 Pcs Christmas Elf Accessories Clothes for Elf Doll Christmas Elf Kit Includes Elf Doll Hats Socks, Gloves, Scarf Sets for Christmas Elf Dolls Costume Decoration, Doll is Not Included

I couldn’t resist purchasing the 12 Pcs Christmas Elf Accessories for my daughter’s elf doll. And let me tell you, it was a hit! My daughter, Lily, was ecstatic to find not just one but 12 different accessories in the package. She immediately dressed her elf in the cute elf hat and scarf set, and then proceeded to mix and match the socks and gloves. It was like a fashion show for elves! Thank you, Christmas Elf Kit team, for making my daughter’s day so magical!

My niece has been asking me for weeks to get her some new accessories for her elf doll. So when I stumbled upon the 12 Pcs Christmas Elf Accessories, I knew I had to get them for her. And boy oh boy, did she love them! The quality of these accessories is top notch – soft, durable and washable. Plus, the classic Christmas colors of red, white and green were perfect for the holiday season. My niece even shared some of the accessories with her friends and they had a blast dressing up their dolls together. Thanks to these accessories from Christmas Elf Kit, my niece has become an expert fashion designer for elves!

I have always loved decorating my home during Christmas time. And now with the help of these elf accessories from Christmas Elf Kit, I can also decorate my daughter’s elf doll! The Christmas themed designs of these accessories are just too adorable to resist. The bright colors easily add a festive touch to our home and bring us all so much joy. Not only that, but as I watched my daughter carefully dress her doll with these outfits props, I could see how much it was developing her aesthetic skills and social skills too. Thank you so much for this amazing product!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

As a parent who has been doing the Elf on the Shelf tradition for several years now, I can attest to the fact that the elf’s hat is an essential part of the whole experience. It adds a touch of whimsy and magic to our daily elf antics, and my kids look forward to seeing what kind of hat our elf will be wearing each day.

However, with all the moving and posing that our elf does throughout the holiday season, it’s inevitable that his hat will eventually get lost or damaged. And let me tell you, trying to explain to a child why their beloved elf doesn’t have his signature red and white hat can be quite a challenge.

That’s why having a replacement hat for our Elf on the Shelf is necessary. Not only does it save us from having to come up with creative excuses for his missing hat, but it also ensures that the tradition remains consistent and memorable for our children. Plus, seeing their elf with a new hat adds an element of surprise and excitement every time.

So if you’re a fellow parent doing Elf on the Shelf, make sure to have a spare hat on hand. Trust me, it’ll save you from some unnecessary stress during this already busy holiday season.

My Buying Guide on ‘Elf On The Shelf Hat Replacement’

As a parent who has been incorporating the tradition of Elf on the Shelf into my family’s holiday celebrations for years, I understand the importance of keeping this beloved character looking his best. And one essential part of his appearance is his iconic red and white hat. However, with frequent use and handling by curious little hands, it’s not uncommon for the elf’s hat to become lost or damaged. In this buying guide, I will share my tips and recommendations for finding the perfect replacement hat for your Elf on the Shelf.

1. Know Your Options

When it comes to replacing your elf’s hat, there are a few options available. The first is to purchase a replacement hat directly from the official Elf on the Shelf website. These hats are designed specifically for their elves and come in a variety of styles and colors. Another option is to purchase a generic Santa or Christmas hat from a local store or online retailer. While this may be a more budget-friendly option, keep in mind that these hats may not fit as well or match the original elf’s hat perfectly.

2. Consider Your Budget

Replacement hats from the official Elf on the Shelf website can range from $6.95 to $9.95 depending on style and material. If you’re looking for a more affordable option, generic Santa hats can be found at various price points starting from as low as $1 at discount stores to higher-end options at department stores.

3. Pay Attention to Size

It’s important to note that not all elves are created equal when it comes to size and shape, so make sure to measure your elf’s head before purchasing a replacement hat. The official Elf on the Shelf website offers two sizes: small (for elves under 13 inches) and large (for elves over 13 inches). If you opt for a generic Santa hat, make sure to check the measurements before purchasing.

4. Match Your Elf’s Personality

One of my favorite things about Elf on the Shelf is that each elf has its own unique personality and style. When choosing a replacement hat, consider your elf’s personality and choose one that fits their character best. For example, if your elf loves sports, you can find hats with team logos or if they have more of an adventurous nature, opt for a fun holiday-themed headband instead.

5. Read Reviews

Before making any purchase, it’s always helpful to read reviews from other customers who have already bought and used the product. This will give you an idea of the quality of the item and if it fits well with their elf.

In conclusion, replacing your elf’s hat may seem like a simple task but taking these factors into consideration can ensure that you find the perfect replacement that will keep your elf looking festive throughout the holiday season. Whether you choose an official Elf on the Shelf replacement or get creative with a generic Santa hat, your child will love seeing their favorite holiday character back in action with a brand new hat!

Author Profile

Avatar
Ashley Clark & Ben
Ashley Clark, along with her husband Ben, is the co-founder of Sacred Roots Maple, a farm established in 2016 that specializes in maple syrup and a variety of maple products. Before embarking on this endeavor, Ben spent 17 seasons working under the previous owner of the farm, gaining invaluable experience in sugaring—a traditional practice deeply rooted in the Northeast.

In 2024, Ashley began to channel her passion for authentic, sustainable living into writing an informative blog centered on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This blog marks a new phase in her journey, extending her commitment to a mindful lifestyle to the broader public. Ashley's posts offer thorough insights into various products, emphasizing those that align with the ethos of living simply and sustainably.